Investing Principle #11 – Past Performance Is No Indicator of Future Performance

Judging an investment based on recent past performance could also turn out to be a mistake, find out how to rely on the market principles based on evidence instead.
9 September 2020
past performance is no indicator of future performance

Judging an investment based on recent past performance could also turn out to be a mistake

Have you ever waited a long time to watch a movie directed by a renowned filmmaker who had clinched many Oscar and Emmy awards in the past, only to be disappointed by its lackluster script after you have watched it?

Just as how we cannot judge a movie based on the past achievements of a movie director, judging an investment based on recent past performance could also turn out to be a mistake.

Research shows that past performance offers little insight into a fund’s future returns as most US-domiciled equity and fixed-income funds in the top quartile of previous five-year returns did not maintain a top-quartile ranking in the following five years.

percentage of top ranked funds

Source: Dimensional, Morningstar.

History can serve as a good guide to form evidence-based investment principles such the markets will always recover the in long run; stocks will generally outperform bonds; and how even within stocks, higher expected returns can come from stocks of smaller companies, that are cheaper relative to its assets, and have positive cash flows.

However, looking at only the past performance of individual funds to decide which one to invest in is similar to driving forward while looking backward. Instead, rely on the market principles based on evidence, not what the market did or will do in the short term, to help you make sensible investment decisions.

This is likened to using real-time traffic information to get a more accurate estimation of the time it takes to get to another place, compared to past information found on the Internet.

This series is adapted from the book, 27 Principles Every Investor Should Know, written by Steven J. Atkinson. Read the rest of the principles:

Author: MoneyOwl’s Solutions Team

Share this

More Articles From MoneyOwl

Stay informed on our latest updates and happenings.

The equity market outlook may look challenging, but our investment team shares how you can benefit from the market situation.
4 Oct 2022


The UK's budget triggered a sell-off in gilts, driving the UK sterling pound to record lows. Global currencies are not unaffected either and our CEO and Chief Investment Officer weighs in on the way forward.
30 Sep 2022

CIO Letter

There are many cash management accounts in the market but which is the best? We find out why WiseSaver stands out amongst the rest.
30 Sep 2022